Customer Reviews

Kathryn Kellen
Kathryn Kellen
We couldn't be happier from the first contact through the end of our projects! The quality work, integrity and professionalism of everyone involved was impressive. All the guys were very personable. We felt very comfortable having them working in our home- even in the midst or COVID-19! With a new front door and whole house windows installed in addition, our Kitchen/Sunroom remodel was completed on time and on budget. We will continue to recommend Sims Exteriors and Remodeling to our friends, and would definitely use them again for future needs!
Dan Zimmerman
Dan Zimmerman
Sims replaced our roof with quality materials at a cost that is competitive with other elite roofing companies. They provide a 10 year workmanship guarantee and GAF provides a 50 year transferable warranty on the shingles. The workers showed up on time and completed our roof replacement within one day.
cheryl alt
cheryl alt
My experience with sims was fantastic! They exceeded all my expectations! They were prompt on Time. Communication was fantastic! Very curious, listened to me, workmanship was superior. Couldn’t be more satisfied! Would classify them five stars. No add on prices. I would highly recommend them!
Carmen Rasmussen
Carmen Rasmussen
Jeff Beinborn
Jeff Beinborn
Betty Sisk
Betty Sisk
Debra Parkin Marks
Debra Parkin Marks
In January we had a remodel done of our front entry and dining room. The guys from Sims were professional and personable to work with. They were considerate of our being home during construction and made every effort to work quickly when exterior walls and windows were being replaced. We love the finish product and can't wait for them to take on our siding job this spring.
Nancy Richardson
Nancy Richardson
Wonderful company. When I hired Sims in 2009, I had never really hired someone for a roofing project before. I had lots of questions. Mr. Sims met with me to answer all my questions and worked with me to make the project a success. Sims Exteriors has the expertise and experience to compete with bigger companies while offering the personal touch of a smaller company. When you work with Sims, you honestly get the best of both worlds.
Tad Pinkerton
Tad Pinkerton
I've had Sims do work on three houses I've owned, and their work has always been first rate. When a problem occurred, they spent considerable time ensuring that it was pursued until resolved.
Carol McNeill
Carol McNeill
Sims Exteriors and Remodeling makes dreams come true!!! I highly recommend this TRUSTWORTHY company. They completed a long-awaited major renovation in our home. JW encouraged our dreaming, and helped us choose a skylight which they installed over our breakfast bar. Our kitchen is now filled with light for cooking and baking and art projects, and we have the fun of looking up to see the stars and moon at night as well as cloud formations and helicopter flyovers during the day. This is in line with our decorating plan to “bring the outdoors inside.” Nate is a superb project manager and great communicator and was careful to consider every detail. He explained the various features of window styles, helping us to choose the right styles. Nate kept us informed of timelines, and was polite and flexible. We are pleased with the high quality windows and doors they installed. Above all, each of the workmen were trustworthy, skilled, on-task, personable, and open to questions, suggestions and feedback. We felt very comfortable with these men of integrity in our home for extended periods when we were not in the house. They were also very gracious on days when I was at home, sometimes following them around and inspecting their work. They were well organized, prepared, always on time or early, and in general just very thoughtful. Cleanup was thorough. Special thanks to Joaquin for exceptional attention to detail, and to Eric and Bill for their above average painting skills. Thanks to Jon for the roof work, and the many others who helped. We appreciate all of you.
Topher Day
Topher Day
The workers were very polite and respectful and picked up after themselves. They even came back after the snow melted to run their magnet all around the house to collect any stray nails out of the yard. The style and color we chose really raised our house's curb-appeal.
Cynthia Gramm
Cynthia Gramm
We purchased a home a little over a year ago. The soffits were rotting and during our first winter, there was serious ice-damning. We were advised to do an energy audit before making any repairs, which we did. The energy audit showed that our roof was not insulated and substantial heat loss was occurring. There was also evidence that some of the roof decking might have water damage. We ended up hiring Sims Exteriors to replace the roof and the soffits. They partnered with Cellar to Attic, who installed foam insulation. We obtained multiple estimates before making this choice. Sims' estimate was neither the highest nor the lowest. We chose them for 4 reasons: (1) Their project managers seemed more knowledgeable, noticing some problems with our roof and soffits that others had not noticed (e.g., "sponginess" in some areas indicating that the underlying roof decking had suffered water damage; improperly hung gutters, etc.; (2) they were Better Business Bureau members; and (3) they had an A+ Better Business Bureau rating; (4) they had been in business for many years. We were very pleased with their work. It took a long time to get it done because they needed at least 3 days with a dry forecast to do the job, which included removing the roof decking and installing foam. Once the weather cooperated and they could start, they worked nearly every daylight hour to get it completed before the next round of rain. The crew was very courteous and cleaned up after itself daily; the project managers kept us informed on progress.We were pleased with the work and would also note that their warranty was better than that offered by the roofer who had installed the last roof on our house. I definitely recommend them.
Ann Peterson
Ann Peterson
SIMS did such a great job on our roof that we hired them to replace the siding on our entire home as well. Their work is professional and beautifully done and very affordable; competitively priced.They were very quick, and they cleaned up the premises every day. No nails or trash to worry about.HIGHLY RECOMMENDED A+++++
Robert Miller
Robert Miller
We had a serious leak in from our roof and called three companies to look where the leak came through our bedroom ceiling and then try to find where the roof was leaking and give us an estimate on the cost of repairs. The first person was unable to find the exact source of the leak and said they would need to remove shingles, look for any water damage and then give us an estimate. The second person was pretty sure he knew where the leak in the roof was and thought it might cost one thousand dollars or more to fix it. The third person was from Sims. In a little less than an hour he found the source of the leak and fixed it. In several heavy rains since his repair our roof has not leaked.If we ever need any future estimate and/or repairs for our house we will only call Sims.Sincerely, Bob Miller
Wendy Jensen
Wendy Jensen
SIMS put in 2 new sliding doors and they did a fantastic job. The workers were very nice and professional and made sure everything looked great. We will definitely be using them for future projects.
Jeff Murkve
Jeff Murkve
Sims did a great job on our home! The final result looks so good and the work is top notch!
Laurie Redman-Steen
Laurie Redman-Steen
Great people who do great work -- on time and on budget! I wholeheartedly recommend working with them.
M K
M K
Sims did a great job! I had wind damage on the roof and had the roof replaced. Jon was great, he installed a temp cover so the roof would not leak and by providing an accurate quote with a good price. Jon answered all questions he even answered later in the evening after hours. The crew was awesome! The crew was hard working and very conscientious. They did an excellent job and the cleanup was outstanding! Jon and the crew went above and beyond and I would highly recommend them!
Linda Heitzinger
Linda Heitzinger
Prompt and Professional. Job well done. Very Satisfied.
B Henningfield
B Henningfield
Very professional and great quality work. They will fix any little things that need fixing after a project is done. Would recommend them in a heart beat!
Warner Risser
Warner Risser
I would definitely recommend Sims! They do great work, were very organized, prompt, and friendly. Jon answered all my questions and is very cordial and down to earth. He had a great crew of friendly dedicated and hard workers come out to re-roof my house 🙂 Very happy with the entire experience!
Ann Schmitter
Ann Schmitter
Joaquin did a wonderful job on a tricky roof repair. Finished it all in one day, removed all the old nasty wood, adjusted the gutter and left it looking terrific!!! Great job and we will definitely work with the company again. Already working on an estimate for another project for us. Thank you Joaquin and SIMS exteriors.
William Kaether
William Kaether
Robert Schoewe
Robert Schoewe
Jon was always on top of everything. Setting appointments , explaining the estimate, warranty, and scheduling. Marcos and the crew were prompt and got right to work. They protected the property and cleaned up the site everyday after work. They kept the house weather tight under some trying circumstances. Couldn’t have happier with Jon, Marcos and the crew, and with Sims! I’d recommend them!
Fort Higgs
Fort Higgs
Sims re-sided our very old house and re-roofed said house as well as our garage. Both crews did really quality work. They worked methodically and didn't hurry and their attention to detail was all we could ask for. Our old house looks great and will for a long time - at least on the outside.
Tim Jones
Tim Jones
James Graves
James Graves
SIMS Exteriors and Remodeling did a fantastic job for us. They where efficient, professional, and timely. They did the exterior of our home and we are extremely pleased with their work. I would highly recommend them to anyone.
Andrew Kitslaar
Andrew Kitslaar
I cannot recommend Sims more highly! We had an amazing experience from start to finish. They were super helpful in guiding us through our exterior work planning, selection and execution, they answered all of our questions thoroughly, their communication was quick and detailed, and their attention to detail was stunning. On top of all that, they were very affordable. We really enjoyed working with Sims and would be eager to recommend them to anyone looking to have exterior work done on their house.
Jerry & Pam L
Jerry & Pam L
SIMS recently completed a large job on our house; replacing our siding, roof, and front door. We couldn’t be happier with the results and would not hesitate to use SIMS again or recommend them highly to others. We believe it is It is unusual to find a contractor who has such a commitment to doing a quality job; both in their workmanship, which was top notch, and in their customer service, which quite frankly, was exceptional. One of the most important things in a project like this is to work with a contractor that will not only do a quality job, but one you can depend on; who will come through for you, answer your questions, respond to your concerns, and take good care of their customer. SIMS did that. More than once during the project we felt very grateful to be working with a contractor like that! We appreciated our project manager Nate Gascho, who really knew what he was doing and remained closely engaged with our project throughout. And we appreciated Alladio and our crew, whose skill and experience were apparent and who were a pleasure to have around. At the end of this project, we have a house that looks beautiful and a good feeling about the experience we had with our contractor. Could not ask for more!
Thomas Miller
Thomas Miller
I have used SIMS three times over the past few years. Two roofs and new windows. I have just asked them for a quote on redoing my porch windows. I have recommended them to my neighbors who are pleased with their work. I rate them 5 stars.
Eric Schwab
Eric Schwab
On budget, on time, and a great roofing job! Professional crew and they left no trace. Highly recommended.
Tiffany Kvalheim
Tiffany Kvalheim
George Masaros
George Masaros
I am very pleased with the roofing job that Sims did for me. Jon Gorr explained every step of the process and answered all of my questions thoroughly when reviewing the proposal.He was always accessible during the installation giving frequent updates on the progress that was being made. His crew did an excellent job.They were punctual and courteous. Always cleaned up the job site at the end of each day.I would highly recommends Sims for your roofing needs.
Robert Muranyi
Robert Muranyi
I have used Sims Exteriors for many projects around our house including windows, siding, roofing, filling woodpecter holes and fixing windows. I have been very satisfied with there work and the price is fair. I trust them to do the work properly, quickly and fairly.Rob Muranyi
Ashley Vande Burgt
Ashley Vande Burgt
SIMS exteriors and remodeling is top notch. Good communication, excellent work, and they stand behind the work they do! We've had exterior and interior work performed by SIMS and are very pleased with both. Thanks JW!
Bruce Cornwell
Bruce Cornwell
Enjoyed working with all of the individuals I interacted with Sims. They were polite and courteous. Knowledgeable about their work and very professional. We had roof, gutters, leaf guard and one window done. Quality of the material was exceptional as well of workmanship. They took great measures to clean up after the job was done. You get what you pay for and I believe we got very good quality work and material. After 35 years the house was in need of some serious work. I well be using them again. I would highly recommend Sim's and their knowledgeable and trained personal.
Steve Orth
Steve Orth
We are very glad in our decision to use SIMS Exteriors for our new roof. Jon has been a tremendous asset during this entire process. Unlike other roofing contractors we interviewed, SIMS was very down-to-earth to speak with, and never used high-pressure sales tactics. In fact, Jon was very patient with us as we asked all our questions, presented all our concerns, and asked for numerous customer references.Additionally, Jon was with us for the duration of the project, including being on-site to ensure the project went as discussed, and there after the sale to ensure our concerns were addressed.We would highly recommend SIMS as a roofing contractor and wish more companies exhibited the same level of customer care and concern!
dave beavan
dave beavan
Beautiful job on my roof. Communication was good. I would recommend Sims.
tram chew
tram chew
Just like always when something happens we now rely on the internet for good quality help and services. SIMS is as advertised! They came in as scheduled explained the procedures and completed the repair. And yes at a very respectful rate. Their customer service alone was worth the cost. Thanks
Ryan Liegel
Ryan Liegel
Had my roof replaced about 1 year ago. Consultation was scheduled quickly and we were actually able to get roof replaced less than 1 week after I originally called. Price was middle of the range compared to other estimates I got. Crew finished everything in 1 day and cleaned up pretty well.The SIMS rep I worked with throughout the process was very responsive and went out of his way to make sure a couple things I requested were taken care of. One year later, we've had no issues with the roof so far.
Phyllis Micke
Phyllis Micke
Pleasure to recommend. Sims replaced three roofs - very nice work, very pleasant to work with, quality materials. Would use again.
Michelle Diaz
Michelle Diaz
We love Sims, they did an outstanding job!We would hire them again because there work is excellent.
Vernon Yelk
Vernon Yelk
All experiences with this transaction were satisfactory completed. I would recommend SIMS for your next project.
Richard Anderson
Richard Anderson
Sims Exteriors replaced a roof & siding for me after hail storm damage. They were on time for the project, cleaned up well after completion and had fair pricing for the the work completed. There have been no issues with the work since completion and I would use them again.
Dan Kranda
Dan Kranda
We resided our house with Sims and would certainly recommend working with them on such a project. From the start, they helped us understand the pros and cons of the different materials. They were also very helpful in answering all of our questions about the process in general and the specific concerns we had with our house.The workers that came out were very professional, and our main contact Nate was a joy to work with. He did a great job staying in touch with us and keeping us updated on the progress with the house. I think our favorite thing working with Sims was how far beyond they went. When discussing residing our house, they brought up several other potential enhancements to our house that would make sense during the project: new hose bibs, new storm door, new vents, etc. Nate did a great job involving us in those discussions and organizing the different folks needed to complete the job. When everything was all done, we had a brand new looking house complete with several small upgrades giving us peace of mind over our property. Even with the little additions, we had no surprises with our final invoice which was great. We'll certainly be keeping Sims in mind whenever it comes time for another major home improvement project.
John Melius
John Melius
Professional crew and professional results.
Jane Richards
Jane Richards
I am so impressed with the work Aaron Harrison and his entire team did on my remodel project (kitchen, master bath, powder room, walk-in closet/laundry). Everyone involved was professional, friendly, and very skilled at their craft. Aaron was a joy to work with - very good communication and follow up to details. Work was completed on time and on budget. I highly recommend Sims for honest, quality workmanship.
Kevin Ewert
Kevin Ewert
Very friendly and easy to work with. I will definitely use them for future projects.
Bonnie Schumacher
Bonnie Schumacher
SIMS installed new roof in 2008 and did a great job. More recently, they returned to fix roof damage caused by tree branches, corrected improperly installed installation and redirected bathroom fan from venting into my attic to venting outside, which is how it should have been installed by original builders! Prompt and friendly service, reasonable pricing, conscientious and thorough work. I will definitely use them in the future for any roofing related needs, and recommend them highly!
bruce briney
bruce briney
Sims Exteriors resided our house and we could not be more pleased. The project was done timely and for exactly what we were told it was cost. The employees on the job were courteous and friendly. Every day they cleaned up and there never was any trash left on the site. If we need any other work done I will definitely call Sims.
Sandy Otteson
Sandy Otteson
They kept with the price quoted. We were very happy with the workers. Happy with the final project.We would definitely recommend Sims Exteriors.
jim haidinger
jim haidinger
The crew did a very fine job installing a new sliding patio door. The new door looks great and works great.
Bob Huff
Bob Huff
My wife and I have used Sims Exteriors for several projects over the last 5 years. We are highly satisfied with their workmanship and what the finished product looked like. All the installers that have worked with us were very knowledgeable and took great pride in the work they did. Love the end results and we would Highly recommend Sims for any project you are looking at as their quotes for the projects were better than we anticipated.
Steve Ruscko
Steve Ruscko
Sims did a great job on a tear off and replacement of the roof on a fourplex, working through a "warm" stretch in January. Jon was knowledgeable and easy to work with. Competitively priced.
Karen Hromadka
Karen Hromadka
Great job and a good price. Had a call-back for some shingles and they were right on top of it! Will use them for some other work for sure. Friendly and fast. Cleaned up well, too!
Kelly McDowell
Kelly McDowell
Wendy Schneider
Wendy Schneider
2 years ago we had Sims fix our chimney siding, roof flashing, and replace garage windows/door frame and front doors. They did a fantastic job and the employees were cheerful and polite. This year we plan to replace our deck and privacy fence, plus repair a balcony. Looking forward to working with the Sims team again.
Joe Myers
Joe Myers
Kate Vander Molen
Kate Vander Molen
Sims just completed my "dream" project.(April 2019) I recently moved to a condo that needed updates to the bathrooms and kitchen. I just can say enough about how wonderful this company is. Starting with Aaron, He's so kind, and compassionate. He gave me great ideas, suggestions and most of all a fair price. The carpenters are super as well. Shout out to Mike and Bubba who dealt with my bothersome questions and concerns in such a kind and friendly manner. (they were super with my dog as well who thought she was their supervisor !) The sub-contractors were also great.Professional, attention to detail, kind, excellent workmanship, and helpful would be how to describe the Sims crew. I would highly recommend them. Like JW says on the commercial " Better call Sims"Thank you to Sims for making my dream a reality. I love my new home.
Amy Childs
Amy Childs
Great local company to work with. Jon was great at answering all my questions, they were competitive in pricing, and we were able to get my leaky roof fixed before the snow!
Brett Fankhauser
Brett Fankhauser
Great work!! Area was free of debris after the job!! Roof looks great!!! Will use Sims again!
Mark Roelke
Mark Roelke
Sims Exteriors did a roofing job on our home this spring, Project Manager, Jon Gorr, did an excellent job communicating with us throughout the project. The crew was timely and completed the project in just two days! The hard working roofing crew did a meticulous job keeping the site picked up as work progressed. We are very pleased with the results.
John Larson
John Larson
As part of our roof replacement last year, we identified an area on the roof susceptible to ICE DAMS. The Sims crew created a plan to correct the situation. It involved adding additional ventilation and insulation to the area. We also had to repalce the actual roof panels before the area could be reshingled. After this winter I am happy to say the repair coupled with the new shingles solved the ice dam issue. No sign of dampness or ice melt. The project leader Jon was great when it came to communication and planning. The crew was very focused on the job and our yard was clean after the project - we did not find even one nail. High marks all around - we recommend Sims highly.
Kent Miller
Kent Miller
Sims did a siding job on our home and met or exceeded all of our expectations. They were courteous and efficient. When we requested a change to our original job (adding shutters to windows) they quickly gave us a new estimate and proceeded with the job, still completing it on time and on budget. They did an excellent cleanup after work was completed. When I’m ready for more home improvements you can be sure I’ll call Sims.
judy klingforth
judy klingforth
Rick & Kolene Manogue
Rick & Kolene Manogue
Jim Palmer
Jim Palmer
From the first consultation to installation, I've been very impressed. My large front window needed a customer order. Nate and his team were able to get the order right. The installation team was excellent and was in and out without a trace in about 1/2 day. The Veteran Discount was very appreciation. Recommend to anyone looking for new windows.
Jane Weier
Jane Weier
When we decided to have our 50+ yr old kitchen gutted & remodeled, we immediately called Sims. They had done great work for us--a new roof, siding, new interior doors & trim--so we knew from past work, we could trust them to do it right. Aaron was amazing to work with. He told us what to expect every step of the way & always kept us informed. Their work was superb! The kitchen--from demo to done--was ON BUDGET and ON TIME! And included new flooring, cupboards, plumbing, electrical, counter top and back splash. Friends were amazed at how quickly it was done and we LOVE IT! (see before/after photos)
terry powell
terry powell
We hired Sims remodeling to redo our bathroom. They came when they said they would. It was finished ahead of schedule. It turned out better then my husband and I expected. The workmanship was outstanding. I would definitely hire them again!!
Carla Mondi
Carla Mondi
We just had our roof replaced by Sims and everything went very smoothly. Everyone showed up on time and was courteous throughout the entire procedure. I'd highly recommend them!
Dan Borgrud
Dan Borgrud
Excellent workmanship and quality . The job was scheduled quickly and all work was completed in 2 days . Workers were professional and worked during extreamly hot weather to complete my roof. All aspects of the job were explained well and the results were excellent .I am very pleased to have Sims complete my roofing needs . One issue was found upon completion and it was corrected the following day , Sims ensured me of 100% satisfaction . I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for quality and satisfaction of a job well done .
Gabe Westmont
Gabe Westmont
Overall we were very pleased with the work on the roof. After the work was done, we noticed the crew had missed several nails in the grass during cleanup and we were concerned for the safety of our dog. When we notified Nick of the problem during his final inspection of the job, he immediately called workers in to go over the entire area again. Nick and his crew went above and beyond to make sure we were happy and even helped fix a few additional problems we had outside the scope of the roof replacement. Great customer service!
Robert Mucci
Robert Mucci
We contacted 3 roofing companies to replace our roof. All of the quotes were within 5% of each other and so we decided to work with the firm who had been most responsive to our request and needs - Sims Roofing. Nick came out and walked us through all the steps that would be taken and reviewed everything with us. The company called 2 days prior to installation to confirm and the crew of roofers arived ontimeand did the entire job in two days. There was a crew of about 6 guys and they worked hard and did an awesome job. They cleaned up as they went and at the end of each work day as well. As another reviewer stated, this included walking around picking up nails and any trash, cleaning out the bushes and trees with a leaf blower and sweeping all hard surfaces. While working they were extremely careful to move or cover any items that may be damaged by falling shingles while they were removing the old roof. They put flashing where needed, replaced wood where necessary, did all the things you would expect good roofers to do. They worked well together, they all seemed to know what to do and how to do it. I have yet to find a nail in the grass they are just very detail oriented and professional. Nothing like the storm chasing roofers you see sometimes.We were so happy with their work we had them replace our shutters and have also contacted them to replace to garage windows. They did a great job and we will recommend this company to everyone!Robert & Jan MucciMadison, WI
Gina Eggert
Gina Eggert
We had new shilgles put on our roof by Sims Roofing. Nick came out and walked us through all the steps that would be taken and reviewed everything with us. When the roofers came, they did the entire job in two days. There was a crew of about 6 guys and they worked hard and did an awesome job. They cleaned up as they went and at the end of each work day as well. This included walking around picking up any thing they had missed earlier, cleaning out the bushes and trees with a leaf blower and sweeping all hard surfaces.While working they were extremely careful to move or cover any items that may be damaged by falling shingles while they were removing the old roof. They put flashing where needed, replaced wood where necessary, did all the things you would expect good roofers to do. They worked well together, they all seemed to know what to do and how to do it.We will recommend this company to everyone!
Victoria Sutton
Victoria Sutton
Sims performed a complete tear-off and re-roofing job for me, and they were fantastic. They had been referred to me by another contractor that I trust, and while it wasn't the cheapest estimate I got, I'm glad I went with them - I certainly got my money's worth. They (Nate and crew) were professional, knowledgeable, friendly, and accommodating, including scheduling the job quickly to meet my needs. They encountered a couple of unexpected problems during the job, and in one case took care of it without a hiccup (and were very generous with a price reduction on the additional work), and in the other case gave me great referrals (and another price break) for a more complex problem, and they ultimately coordinated the multi-contractor follow-up work for that problem (wonderfully). The roof is really beautiful, and I have the satisfaction of knowing that the job was well done (no surprises or shortcuts). They were done on time and cleaned up everything, and the only sign of their presence afterward was the beautiful roof. And, when we sell the house, the 10-year transferable warranty on their work (plus the 50-year warranty on the shingles) will be a great selling point. I recommend Sims very highly.

Areas We Serve

  • Madison
  • Middleton
  • Sun Prairie
  • Verona
  • Fitchburg
  • Waunakee

Click for more…

Services

  • Roofing
  • Siding
  • Replacement Window
  • Remodeling
  • Skylights
  • Gutters

Referrals

Our Location

202 West Cottage Grove Road
Cottage Grove, WI 53527
(608) 825-4500

View Map

Copyright © 2018 Madison Exteriors and Remodeling All rights reserved